[Shit Quality] Mansway 55665 by Julian boots defected

I thought I could leisurely a few months …
I did not expect after “[Unboxing] tragedy Julian Boots” article, one reader wrote message to me …

As a most honest man in the fashion discussion board.
After a series of QC Julian boots storms from JB’s Taiwanese dealer”Eternity Wings”, at least more than ten readers asked me privately: If I really really want to buy JB, but I don’t want to buy it in “eternity wings”, where to buy JB?

I consider myself very fair, I had to observe and collect data to respond: In addition to its own brand of boots, the boots OEM by JB doesn’t seems to get any disaster so far…
That’s way when JB was on Barneys sale (60%), but I didn’t take the initiative to share this information.Only readers privately message to me, I always say that price is worth the bet …
I saw the Rising & Sun boots OEM by JB before , the actual touched and seen, in theory, I can also accept that quality control.
Until last week, After the reader “Mr. M”, his article”[Unboxing] tragedy Julian Boots“, I was very ashamed. Then, another reader privately message to me and complaints that the Mansway boots OEM by JB don’t as good as I had spoken publicly. 
Although I did not take any benefit from JB, of course, the great gift “Criminal Procedure”document from “Eternity Wings” I got…
I have a dare to dare, so I will again recommend the OEM boots by JB passively. 
Because of my recommendation, at least two readers into the jaws of death harm …
I would want a public apology and sincere appeal: Me, now, am not recommending any shoes or products made by Julian boots. If readers meet the disaster with JB, I will be exempt from any liability and the law on moral.
We take a look about this Mansway pair how makes me speechless ..
Of course, if you can accept standard, it shows once again that I am not fit with this kind of noble work boots.

原本想說本胖可以清閒閉關個幾個月…
沒想到在[開箱文] 杯具的Julian Boots這篇之後, 又有鄉民私下PM給我…

身為一個時尚版最不典範的表率, 在翅膀店JB事件的QC連環爆之後,
我數次公開, 包含至少超過十位鄉民私下PM問我: 如果真的硬要買JB, 但是又不想跟翅膀店有瓜葛, 那該哪裡買?

我自認非常公道的, 以我觀察與收集過的資料來回應:除了JB自有品牌的靴子, 其他幫人代工的到目前為止, 似乎沒有傳出任何災情過, 所以像是Barneys在六折出清, 雖然我第一時間看到, 但是不主動分享這樣的資訊, 只有私下PM我的, 我都是以這樣的價位值得賭看看…又如萬事威的高端系列, 在北斗大率先開箱以來, 也沒聽聞過JB代工的高端系列有何災情…加上, 我看到JB替Rising & Sun代工的靴子, 實際摸過看過, 理論上我都還可以接受….

直到, 上個星期M大這篇[開箱文] 杯具的Julian Boots之後, 本胖間接自己打臉之後, 某位鄉民接著PM給我, 表示萬事威的JB代工款也不如我原先公開講的那樣保險…

雖然我沒拿JB半點好處, 更不用說翅膀店送的那張刑事告訴狀…
我一項敢做敢當, 所以才會再被動推薦JB代工的款式,
因為我的緣故, 檯面上至少害了兩個鄉民入虎口…

我在此要在公開道歉並誠摯的呼籲:本胖, 現在開始, 一點都不推薦JB經手過的任何鞋款或產品
以後有鄉民在遇到災情, 本胖將免除法律上與道義上的任何責任

來看看萬事威這雙是怎樣的令我五體投地…
當然, 如果你的標準能接受, 那只是又再一次代表本宅胖不適合高貴的工作靴
——————————————————————————-

 傳說中的萬記鞋盒…
Legendary shoebox of Mansway…

 傳說中沒有打折就很難下定決心接納mansway logo在鞋身上的Fan-tastic高端系列
In the legend, if no discount, it is very difficult to accept that mansway logo in this “Fan-tastic” hi-end series….
 鞋子主人原本開開心心的拿回家要開箱, 一穿出門一下子才發現…在威的老味都無法撫平的穿著不適感
The owner was happy buying it and tried it, but she felt uncomfortable even it looks so nice vintage looking.
 鞋身外觀, 除了我高標得兩隻腳楦頭皮革部位不同之外, 其實看起來還不錯
About the shoe body appearance, except those different leather parts on lasts of 2 feets…I think it is fine.
45度角據說是推坑最好的視角, 萬記委託JB代工的楦頭感覺是比JB的通用楦頭稍微扁平了一點
This last OEM by JB for Mansway is flatter than JB’s generic last.
 傳說中雄赳赳的正面….如果有人看到這裡就知道發生甚麼事, 那本胖無限期加五分鼓勵
The front of look. If anyone know what happen here, I would appreciate your observation.

 兩隻鞋頭面明顯皮革部位不同, 造成的皺褶很明顯不同, 能不能接受, 見仁見智, 本篇不探討
About those different leather parts on those lasts, I don’t want to discuss it now.

 因為接下來才是重頭戲…本宅胖認為, 一雙鞋的最低最低標準, 應該是不能穿到腳受傷….
Because the next is the highlight….I think, the lowest minimum standard pair of shoes should not be worn to a foot injury.

 慎重起見, 盡力拍正角度, 避免不必要的誤會…..正想讚賞筒身高度誤差在水準內的時候…
To be prudent, I try to take a positive angle, to avoid unnecessary misunderstanding. The height of boots boday are under the deviation. It is fine.

 還是先來看看傳說中的貓底撫慰我的心靈一下, 即使貓底根本也不是以前的老底, 復刻來裝舊品XD
The cat’s paw sole.
 左腳內側的沿條收尾, 我覺得靠右那道刻痕明顯露出失手痕跡, 卻又繼續往左調整…
理智上, 我是還能接受, 因為後面的更大條
Ending left foot strip along the inside, I think the score was significantly exposed to the right of that road signs missed, but continue to the left to adjust …
Intellectually, I would be acceptable, because the bigger mistake coming….

 原本想說光外觀幾乎沒啥毛病, 收到鞋之後仔細一看…像是兩隻腳的足弓內側, 竟然明顯不一樣寬…
Those medial arch inside are not same width obviously…..
 我不是李昌鈺, 但是也知道有幾分證據說幾分話…
紙尺拿來插進同一個基準點, 這是右腳, 將近0.9~1左右
My paper ruler inserted into the paper with a reference point, this is the right foot, nearly about 0.9 to 1cm.
 左腳插進去, 將近0.5….我不明白, 皮鞋製成的影片大家應該都看過, 都是包著木頭楦頭在打釘固定,為何會發生兩隻腳這種落差? 因為這位鄉民就是因為穿了, 發現兩隻腳部一樣大, 穿著很不舒服, 才跟我投訴…..
Insert left foot, nearly 0.5 …
I do not understand, we should have seen the movie made shoes are wrapped in wood lasts nailing fixed, Why such a huge difference appeared in the two feet ?
Because the reader tried it and felt two feet are not the same width ,so, wearing uncomfortable, then, complaint to me….
 為了抓出原因, 我在拍個幾乎沒有角度差的兩隻腳內側, 鞋跟都對齊, 請注意看誤差在哪???
To catch the reason, I shot a little angle difference two feet inside the heel are aligned. Please look where is deviation?

 沒錯, 就是整個鞋身的縫製都歪掉了…正面來看很明顯, 
鞋帶孔的位置歪斜, 兩側的鞋片理論上鏡射對齊, 凸出來的那片又非常過頭…
這據說雙W也會出現, 但是會影響到整體鞋身的結構, 我看JB也算是hi-end中的王者…
 看上緣, 由於縫製歪一邊, 所以實際在腳踝的鞋側部分也是歪的….(最左側凸出很多)
 再來看看鞋跟部分…
 我盡力取同角度了, 左腳平放, 前掌會呈現離開水平面
 右腳平放, 則呈現完全貼合水平面…..
 再回來看鞋跟…左鞋跟並沒有完全貼齊水平面, 越往外側約高
 來個特寫
 右腳的鞋跟處理, 雖然沒有出現JB招牌的水平溝縫, 但是在邊緣的磨合實在是….
當然A大應該是能接受, 我是沒辦法接受, 左腳可以平整, 為何右腳就不可以??
 這角度看的出來, 右腳的邊緣幾乎沒有一處是平的, 都是呈現波浪狀線條
 再來看看鞋外側跟中底的距離, 右腳大概是0.4
 左腳大概是0.2….加上內側的數據, 右腳=0.9+0.4=1.3, 左腳=0.5+0.2=0.7, 兩隻腳幾乎差了快一倍…難怪穿起來有一邊楦頭較寬大, 另一邊較狹小的感覺….
 傳說, 古代包青天有公孫策獻計, 現代L胖沒有任何人獻計, 但是CSI影集也看過幾次, 印泥搬出來採證!

 塗滿之後, 放在牛皮紙袋測試, 然後用手加壓
 效果還不錯….就完成第一次科學採證
 第二次正式來, 就塗完印泥, 直接輕放在白紙上, 不做任何加壓動作, 來觀察兩隻腳著力的方式

兩隻腳都乖乖上去….

結果還蠻明顯的….
 負片模式一下更清楚…明顯是右腳後腳跟外緣根本不著地, 左腳前掌外側也不著地, 
所以簡單來說, 兩隻腳都沒有達到每隻腳的平均著地的基本功能…穿久會怎樣, 我不知道…
但是肯定不會舒服, 還有可能受傷….
2014-06-20 修正小更新:
圖中的這雙, 我原本的說法有所謬誤, 在此更正, 
這雙是本文中的靴子, 該鄉民穿了不合腳, 店員進去再拿出來照片中這一雙, 明顯大小腳差太多,
該鄉民才又回頭考慮本文中的這雙並購買….

 看的出來有啥問題嗎??

——————————————————————————-
結論:萬事威的QC應該還是比翅膀店好, 但是第一時間不想處理退換的態度, 還好最後還是有達成共識

這篇揭露的不是實際穿過, 然後又有像本胖一樣做實驗的…
所以, 爺們, 這樣的品質應該離boutique很遠吧…

再次引用中國重量級代購商”列寧”的評論,

 還好有其他網民備份, 成為最中肯的評論

有哪位鄉民能接受這樣的QC, 請留言表態一下, 我想確認是不是我根本不適合工作靴?
——————————————————————————-
再補充前陣子JB連環爆, 受害者之一的網友忍不住寫信去問JB原廠,
這就是JB官方一直對外SOP宣稱的品質…
以下=>
In 7 years we never had any complaints regarding defected boots except for one client in China which was handled by a guy called GAO who is an imposter.
He claims to be a distributor for White’s boots. We called White’s boots and they never heard of him. He is the only one that did not take care of his client.

As far as we know there is only one client that never purchased boots from us or Eternity. Eternity would not sell him any boots since he is a blogger and maybe works for the competition.
How can he has a complaint if he never received any boots. We don’t have any or had any complaints worldwide except on the Chinese forums.

Our boots are all checked for quality control. Of course a mistake can happen. We always replace or fix any boot that has a problem within 1 week.
However to make a new boot will require some time since our boots are all hand made with the best materials available in the world. We use the most expensive and best tannery in the world.
We have some leather specially made for Julian Boots only and it takes a while to make it.

Julian Boots stands by the high quality of its boots and by its great customer service. We have had nothing but satisfied customers for that reason. We have never received a complaint about the quality of our boots.
If anyone has a complaint they should just e-mail us.

I don’t read Chinese. Could you tell me in short words what the complaint is.

Sincerely,

——————————————————————————-
延伸閱讀:
[開箱文] 杯具的Julian Boots
[輕鬆一下] 慶祝2014屆滿註冊六周年紀念閉關活動之預告影片
[世界首創] [超越永遠經典的經典] Redwing 875 Reborn 加工漂白重生靴
[官方認證!!][自編自導自演開箱文] Julian Boots by 永遠之翼ETERNITY & Co
[一刀未剪][英文練習] 我, Julian boots與永遠之翼的感人故事
[What is love?] Red Wings 9111 舊鞋改造計畫教學分享

發表迴響

這個網站採用 Akismet 服務減少垃圾留言。進一步瞭解 Akismet 如何處理網站訪客的留言資料